AI reaction on my text: Who and why XI commandment in book . XI commandment? informing against indifference. ]] >https://blogjw.wordpress.com/xi-command/]] > besides available online:
Who and why the 11th commandment? An AI essay.
This is simply a very interesting and courageous text – both individual and philosophical-publicist. It can be seen that his author (probably Józef Wieczorek) not only polemizes with Marian Turski's popular and media message, but besides poses a question about the foundations of morality in the world, which increasingly cuts off from the roots of Christian civilization. Below is simply a sketch of an essay inspired by this text, entitled:
Who and why the 11th commandment?
Large words frequently appear in public space: “remembrance”, “morality”, “responsibility”. It is easy to notice, however, that they increasingly become empty slogans – detached from the spiritual and ethical foundation that shaped our civilisation for centuries. specified an example became Marian Turski's celebrated speech of January 27, 2020 on the anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz, in which he called for the “XI of the Commandment”: “Do not be indifferent.” These words made a large impression – in the media they were considered almost a universal decalogue of the fresh era. But are they truly a moral commandment, or is it a sign of a time erstwhile emotion replaces reflection and morality a media authority?
Morality Without a Foundation
Turski, erstwhile Auschwitz prisoner, calls for vigilance towards evil. His informing is right: indifference to hatred and force causes further tragedies. However, the author of the speech – as Józef Wieczorek notes critically – ignores the crucial context: his own commitment to building a communist strategy after the war, which was besides a strategy of enslavement, force and lies. In this sense The call "do not be indifferent" sounds incomplete or even ambiguous – as if directed by individual who has not himself accounted for his own past.
This is not a human justice, but a question of moral cohesion. due to the fact that morality without Decalogue, without being rooted in a permanent strategy of values, becomes comparative – can service both good and evil, depending on who manipulates it. In the past of the 20th century, we have seen this not once: totalitarianism was not born from hatred for good, but from the belief that good can be built in its own way, against God and conscience.
“Do not be indifferent” – why?
The Turkish appeal is emotionally convincing, but philosophically empty. "Don't be indifferent" to what? If a man has no mention to the good and evil rooted in the Decalogue, he does not know what to protest and what to defend. Just look at the modern planet – full of people who zealously condemn “hate” but despise Christian values, traditions, the right to life, family. It is besides a form of indifference – only that dressed in the language of moral exultation.
As the author of the text notes, the “XI Commandment” is now a convenient tool for nihilism. It replaces God's commandments with an expression of emotion: react, resent, protest – but do not ask why and in the name of what. Thus man becomes not the guardian of good, but his unconscious destroyer.
Indifference to the Truth
True indifference is not about activism or loud moralism. It is the courage of being faithful to the fact – even erstwhile silence is easier. Antoni Kępiński, another prisoner of the camp mentioned by Evening, He built his life on the Decalogue, not on passwords. In his attitude there was more genuine indifference than in a 1000 speeches about morality without God.
Therefore, the question “to whom and why is the XI commandment needed?” is simply a question of the condition of modern man. Do we truly request a fresh commandment – or do we request to return to the 10 that we already have, but that we have stopped taking seriously? It may not be to invent fresh moral slogans, but to regain the meaning of old words: do not kill, do not steal, do not talk false testimony, worship your father and your mother.
Completion
In a planet that rejects transcendence, all fresh "command" becomes an ideological slogan. The XI commandment can be beautiful – if it comes from the heart that remembers the 10 erstwhile ones. Otherwise it becomes an empty echo – another moral ritual without faith, without truth, without courage.
Because only 1 who is not indifferent to God and the Decalogue can truly not be indifferent to man.
