Ignorant in the White House
Donald Trump evidently hasn't heard of so-called Black September, or the civilian war in Jordan, which was fought by the father of the current king of Jordan Abdullah II, or King Hussein with extremist Palestinian organizations. This war, apart from the fact that it could have led to the dissolution of the Hashemites Kingdom, did not nearly lead to the death of the king.
W The unspoken civilian war between Egypt’s ruling military junta and the Muslim Brotherhood is already under way and, at the same time, with local jihadist organizations and Bedouins in Sinai. Whether it's a fewer 100 1000 or even over a million Palestinians would only add fuel to Islamists. Egypt’s president Abd al-Fattah as-Sisi would gotta remember that 1 of his predecessors — Anwar Sadat — had paid his life besides far in the eyes of Islamists going along with Israel.
False analogy
From the Polish position The thought of mass resettlement looks different, of course. Poland was created within its current borders as a consequence of mass displacements of Germans from our western lands. After the uprising of modern Poland in turn, As part of the alleged Vistula shares, the Ukrainians were forced out of the territories then inhabited by them. However, the difference between the situation of Poland and the situation of Palestinians is fundamental.
Firstly, another standards were in force in 1945 and 1947 and others were in force in 2025. Secondly, the circumstances were fundamentally different. Poland was a victim of German aggression and German genocide and there are no Polish wines that could be explained by this aggression and genocide. In a relation with Ukrainians, pre-war Poland was not blameless, but it besides cannot justify in any way genocide committed in Poles by Ukrainian nationalists.
Presidents Aleksander Kwasniewski and Lech Kaczyński apologized for the action of the Ukrainian Vistula after 1990, and earlier in August 1990 the Polish Senate. There is no way, while maintaining intellectual integrity, to proclaim that the Vistula run had to be apologized for and to support Trump's thought at the same time.
For Palestinians, of course, the thought of carrying out cultural genocidal cleansing can be explained. Hamas attack on Israel of 2023. The point is that there are at least 3 reasons why specified an argument would be powerfully drawn.
First, The ideas of cultural cleansing appeared in Israel – mainly, let's highlight, in the utmost right environment – even before the Hamas attack.
Secondly, in consequence to nearly 1 and a half 1000 civilian victims of the Hamas attack, Israel responded by killing about 45,000 Palestinians, of which about 30,000 were civilians. Of course, 1 can effort to realize that fighting in a densely populated area, civilian casualties could not be avoided. However, it is adequate to look at pictures of the Gaza Strip, which looks like Warsaw after the Warsaw Uprising, to ask itself whether Israel tried to fight so that little and not more civilians would die.
Hasan N. H. Alzaan/Anadol via Getty Images / Contributor / Getty ImagesGaza Strip destroyed by Israeli bombings
Thirdly, past did not begin in 2023. Palestinians have lived under Israeli business for years. The business cannot justify the genocide of Hamas, but it must not be overlooked in describing the reality or conditions of this occupation, Israel's long-standing brutality towards the Palestinians, the very fact of the occupation, and yet recognise that the best way out of the enchanted ellipse of force is cultural cleansing. At the same time, cultural cleansing cannot be supported and Israel is the only democracy in the mediate East.
Old Israel is gone
The thought of displaced Palestinians from the Gaza Strip, which Donald Trump publically announced, but which enjoys the support of the current Israeli authorities is simply a minute erstwhile it should be acknowledged that the Israeli prime ministers Goldy Meier, Shimon Peres and Icchak Rabin are just gone. All these politicians were capable of defending Israel hard. They did not hesitate — and rightly so — to give orders to kill Palestinian activists and leaders who sought terror.
However, no of them crossed that line, after which they were so much like their opponents, that it was hard to separate them from each other.
Unfortunately, modern Israel has nothing to do with the above-mentioned large leaders, as has Prime Minister Icchak Szamir, who accused Poles of anti-Semitism (in which he exaggerated, but to which he was entitled, due to the fact that he himself experienced this anti-Semitism) It has nothing to do with Prime Minister Jair Lapid, who, in order to accuse Poles of anti-Semitism, invented the past of his own family.
Twitter era politicians
Trump and Netanjahu's thought (because that is almost surely the way to specify the thought of the displacement of Palestinians from the Gaza Strip) is simply a manifestation of the triumph of the most primitive knowing of politics.
The size of the above mentioned Icchak Rabin, Shimon Perses, but besides Anwar Sadat's interlocutor at Camp David, Menachem Begin was that, having won, they could take a step backwards.
Trump and Netanjahu, surviving in an era where social media is teeming with expressions specified as "river" and "pull" seemingly believed that, having prevailed, they should take 10 steps forward — and specifically take the chance and Palestinians to "river" and the Gaza Strip, here in a literal sense, "pall".
Their supporters will say that Meier's method, Regina's, Peres', Rabina's gave nothing, and Israel was not safe. In fact, it's precisely the opposite. It is inherently absurd to anticipate that people can be safe erstwhile occupying their territories.
Nearly a 1000 people died during the Hamas attack, yes. But the very existence of Israel since the last Israeli–Arab War, or war Yom Kippur in 1973.There was no danger for a moment. The thought that this will proceed — if the rule that to decision forward, sometimes you gotta take a step backwards, will be replaced by Twitter rules — is at least bravado.
It is besides bravadoful to presume that Israel’s safety can be treated as something without anti-Semitism. This one, thanks to the governments of the far right in Israel, only unfortunately grows.
That is precisely why we should remind that, just as cultural cleansing is simply a crime against humanity, so anti-Semitism is simply a crime against reason, morality, decency – and for believers – besides God.
