You will most likely see the main releases of the TVP News (if you are watching them at all) differently after reading the text below.
In preparing this material, I watched respective twelve releases of the main news service TVP.By doing specified a binge-watching, watching them 1 by one, you can see even more clearly how dramatically this is simply a bad, harmful, distorted and manipulated program that reaches millions of audiences and I think rather seriously in this expression is simply a threat to democracy in Poland.
But let's start over.
I look at the main news sites on Polsata (Events), TVN (Facts) and TVP (News) all now and then to compare different narratives, selection of topics and quality of transmission.
The news plan in most news programs is simple.
There is an event, news announces the host of the edition, a beam with a subject appears (in the news there are already iconic TVP strips, whose the analysis was conducted by the Council of Polish Language any time ago).
Then the narratives are conducted by a writer preparing the material, his message is given by photographs from a peculiar event, by the comments of the protagonists of the material, and by “hundreds” with experts, commentators, sometimes by a probe with “ordinary Poles”. In a good, possibly polarizing material thesis of 1 organization is combined with comments from the opposing party, the final comment belongs to the writer preparing the material. Theoretically, the material should be objective, take into account the opinion of all parties – but let's agree that we can have doubts about objectivity even in the case of a monitoring camera at a gas station. Each station has any circumstantial transmission strategy and the construction of news reporting that can be described and adapted to political or social options.
I pointed out that rather frequently the same faces appear in the function of TVP News commentators. erstwhile I began to analyse and pay peculiar attention, it was actually hard for me to find the release of the News without the participation of individual from the “three musketeers of TVP”:
- Miłosz Manasterski (publicist, Information Agency),
- Artur Wróblewski (politologist, Łazarski University),
- Adrian Stankowski (publicist “Gazeta Polska Daily”)
I took your descriptions from the TVP strips.
Below is simply a brief analysis of the frequency of speeches of the 3 Musketeers TVP conducted from May 5, 2020 (from the end of the long May weekend) to July 11, 2020, which is to vote silence before the second circular of the presidential election.
The full version of the study is at the end of the text and contains the exact statements of the 3 commentators mentioned, the name of the writer preparing the material and the link to the source, most frequently to YouTube (records on TVP websites vanish after a twelve days)
Of course, each station chooses the commentators it wants, tailored to the category of the topic, specialising in circumstantial areas. The point is that TVP is different. Manasterski, Wróblewski, Stankowski can talk on any subject, and the News itself have as simple narratives as a cepa construction – "we praise the government, we beat the opposition" – and in this formula, these experts work perfectly.
In fact, after writing on the bulletin bar, I already know from whom it will come from and what the comment of the expert from the said three, but that's my warp due to the fact that I'm analyzing nearly 70 programs.
You can call Manasterski, Wróblewski and Stankowski for comments on any matter, as long as it complies with the TVP News propaganda line.
There is practically no subject that experts could not comment on – all 3 of them gladly commented on the subject related to the premiere of the documentary Sylwester Latkowski "Nothing happened" – so the argument "a specialist from a peculiar subject" is not to be defended. I wonder if they have always refused to comment due to the fact that it does not concern the subject in which they specialize.
Expert statements News does not sound so bad erstwhile read in the table below. erstwhile you look at the context of these materials and look at the full report, this pushy, repeated message of the News confirms its content.
I think it would be easy to make a simple generator of statements and comments from our “great three” that would fit any material broadcast by the News. I even wondered if any of these speeches were recorded for a fewer days ahead – due to the fact that they are actually inactive about the same thing. Read for yourself any of them – the table below.
And this “continuously about the same thing” is fundamentally the worst and saddest impression I had erstwhile I watched the news releases 1 by one.
Repeated materials, copy+paste shots from the erstwhile day, same issues. Even different journalists in 1 issue frequently do not synchronise their material and images, or the message or the “compromising” statements or situations from the opposition's life are repeated and rolled over the following days if the editorial board considers the subject important.
And our 3 Musketeers are eager to comment.
Truly specified an amateur, specified a low level of communication, even an insulting intelligence of a common man, I am incapable to witness in any media I watch.
I already skip other, various workshop failures (although I am certain they are not random) on the basis of which journalism students could compose the full encyclopedia "how not to do professionally".
An example are street probes – I know, the subject of the river.
It is unusual to see that the same pair of random passersby appear on June 11th and June 16th, without any indication that it is simply a archival statement, and (the most important) nothing in the subject has changed... so why make news? Answer yourselves.
June 11, 2020 material and material from 16 May 2020.
Such a narrow, even monothematic selection of commentators can be assessed at first as an amateur workshop mistake by TVP journalists. If, however, we add to the same faces all day a handmaiden transmission of TVP, treating the viewer like an imbecile, beating him into the head of the same ones, then there is no workshop error, but a kind of media pathology, which has nothing to do with the government's announced restoration of national media pluralism and maintaining media balance.
I wrote in the beginning that most likely after reading this text you will be seeing the main releases of the News TVP completely differently – if you want to watch this sad parody of the news program. You can improve your mood, all time 1 of the 3 Musketeers appears, shout “bingo!” possibly you will hit a “three” – that is, Manasterski, Wróblewski, Stankowski in 1 day – which is not hard at all, looking at the list below. Although alternatively of the joy of winning there will most likely be sadness about the disastrous fall of quality of Polish media.
However, the saddest thing is that according to the rulers, the strategy of specified formatting information media works perfectly, so there is no reason to change anything. In my opinion, the media, which are incapable to ask any hard question to the ruling politicians, are incapable to release any critical comment, and talks, interviews with the people of power are an endless laurels are a serious threat to democracy and awareness of Poles' elections.
Media education, cognition of the process of creating and formatting information, distinguishing fake news, fact checking skills are only any of the skills that a modern citizen should have in a planet filled with information.
I have no uncertainty that the road to specified a state is very long, fewer average consumers feel this need, and media education itself should begin in schools.
Nevertheless, I believe that pathology, bad, harmful practices in the media should be stigmatized, talked about, and active all available mechanisms, ranging from NGOs to courts and legislative power to effort to reconstruct a clear and actual flow of information. Knowledge, information is simply a priceless currency today. On the basis of these, we citizens, local governments, companies, consumers make many crucial life decisions.
What can we citizens do with this pathological media situation?
I don't have a clear prescription and a simple solution for that, but the subject is serious and the subject of entry and analysis of this short, propaganda expert bench is just 1 of many fragments of the corrupt media reality in which we all function.
Analysis of the frequency of speeches of the 3 Musketeers TVP conducted from 5 May 2020 (from the end of the long May weekend) to 11 July 2020, i.e. until the vote silence before the second circular of the presidential election.
| TVP news – release date | Manaster Love | Adrian Stankowski | Artur Wróblewski | What did he say? | The material was prepared | Source |
| 5.55.2020 | x | x | x | Miłosz Manasterski: Who is not with the caste, who is not with the alleged elite, he is simply immediately criticized by the elite as the evil, stupid and possessing no skills. Adrian Stankowski: It is no coincidence that a paper that called the creators of the action "Hiacint" people of honour present takes over their methods and tries to discredit the political opponent by utilizing information of a moral character. That's the worst Ubec method. Artur Wróblewski: There is no uncertainty that the opposition's opposition to elections is due to adverse polls for them, not to the argument about wellness safety, due to the fact that the correspondence vote is the safest one. | Konrad Snake Krzysztof Nowina Konopka | https://youtu.be/ZUzxxs5vsSc?t=873 |
| 6.05.2020 | x | x | x | Miłosz Manasterski: independency is simply a concept at this point very contractual, and in fact the candidate takes with him on a political journey of people stuck in politics but besides possibly in suspicious interests. Artur Wróblewski: erstwhile it comes to his own political interest of the opposition, he is able to bend the law in the legislature and not comply with the rules and regulations of law only to accomplish his stated goal. Adrian Stankowski: Mr Tomasz Grodzki, in fact, is besides questioning democratic governance in Poland, whose elections are the foundation and foundation. | Konrad Warzoch Konrad Snake | https://youtu.be/R1nwS8TAWxc?t=1232 |
| 7.05.2020 | x | x | Miłosz Manasterski: From the beginning this debate was aimed at attacking president Andrzej Duda, practically all candidates, counter-candidates and this attack failed. Adrian Stankowski: A horse with a row of who will answer the question whether Mrs Kidawa-Błońska is moving or not, whether she comes in or out or... This is simply a completely ridiculous attitude, marking a deficiency of respect for us, for voters. | Marcin Tulicki Maciej Sawicki | https://youtu.be/F0QKcmpbph0?t=1257 | |
| 8.05.2020 | x | x | Adrian Stankowski: The Communist caste has made the ultimate Court specified a last snout, which is why they are dragging all possible procedures increasingly desperately in the hope that the inevitable may inactive be postponed. Miłosz Manasterski: However, it is hard to imagine that anyone is simply a worse president of the ultimate Court than Margaret Gersdorf, that he is more a politicised president and acts more to the detriment of the Polish state and, of course, the ultimate Court too. | Adrian Borecki | https://youtu.be/AlNPsASPf_k?t=1301 | |
| 9.05.2020 | x | x | x | Miłosz Manasterski: The opposition plays for election chaos, so that Poles do not truly know how elections are held erstwhile they are held, how they can participate in them, and even who competes in them looking at the actions of Margaret Kidawa-Błońska. The opposition wants to shut down the state. Miłosz Manasterski: After failing to paralyze the Polish state on the occasion of the elections, I immediately expected that something akin would happen in Poland. These are actions that I can describe without hesitation as hybrid actions against the Polish state. Artur Wróblewski: There is simply a sense, among the judges of the old belief, that they are losing influence, and in this way want to make it as hard to choose and incorporate the ultimate Court into the process of reforming the judiciary. | Krzysztof Nowina Konopka Marcin Szypszak Konrad Snake | https://youtu.be/9_j-WCJ7F40?t=1270 |
| 10.05.2020 | x | x | Artur Wróblewski: The opposition is aware that it is losing influence and so is desperately trying to win these presidential elections by delaying them in time. Adrian Stankowski: Especially during the pandemic and economical crisis that threatens us, it is required that all political actors behave responsibly to cooperate with each other. | Krzysztof Nowina Konopka | https://youtu.be/zH1Akbb6-2A?t=1592 | |
| 11.05.2020 | x | x | x | Miłosz Manasterski: Deputy Prime Minister Sasin is simply a key figure in the government and is liable for the supervision of State Treasury companies. His actions and, of course, the operations of the Treasury companies are a pattern. Adrian Stankowski: The opposition has been playing anarchy for years, for causing chaos in the country, and so is the request for resignation of Minister Sasin. This will only strengthen abroad influence. Artur Wróblewski: There was a regulation setting up a squad of experts, there was a squad of experts, very frequently there was quite a few money for experts – after which nothing happened. | Maciej Sawicki Aleksandra Marciniak | https://youtu.be/l4jIY1O9Sgo?t=1324 |
| 12.05.2020 | x | x | Adrian Stankowski: voice problem in the recording Manaster Love: voice problem in the recording | https://youtu.be/0kQX4Qp_hM0?t=1085 | ||
| 13.05.2020 | x | x | x | Artur Wróblewski: People are beginning to see that any people destabilize the state in the name of certain political issues, specified as the weak polls, while another politicians are trying to guarantee that there are crisis shields. Miłosz Manasterski: PO has no rider on white horse, there is no policy that could origin a large revolution. Adrian Stankowski: akin scenarios are written by opposition politicians. This script is always the same – turn Poland off. | Marcin Szypszak Krzysztof Nowina Konopka Konrad Snake | https://youtu.be/HMdZPrnSana?t=984 |
| 14.05.2020 | x | Artur Wróblewski: From the beginning, Mr Grodzki's intention was not to work properly, but, above all, to hold work, in order to hold the presidential elections in Poland, so that the polls of opposition candidates would improve. | Konrad Snake | https://youtu.be/F14wSAbxuqw?t=1048 | ||
| 15.05.2020 | experts were free | |||||
| 16.05.2020 | x | x | Adrian Stankowski: Rafał Trzaskowski turned out to be a very bad host of Warsaw. Warsaw is the richest commune in Poland, and it stands on the brink of bankruptcy. Rafał Trzaskowski tries to escape this situation. Miłosz Manasterski: There was to be a fresh opening, a fresh candidate, and everything indicates that there isIt's just a fresh con, with early signatures. | Maciej Sawicki | https://youtu.be/QfVVMAKqyM?t=1376 | |
| 17.05.2020 | x | Artur Wróblewski: The fact that the president of the Constitutional Court in Germany was a politician shows that Germany has its own definition of the regulation of law, while completely different criteria apply to Poland, for example. | Marcin Szypszak | https://youtu.be/2AxErcJmkcs?t=1643 | ||
| 18.05.2020 | x | Adrian Stankowski: Hence these militant faces of Rafał Trzaskowski, hence shouting, visible nervousness and apparent artificiality. You can see that this run brutality is invented by the staff. | Krzysztof Nowina Konopka | https://youtu.be/J0U8IkLH0ww?t=1427 | ||
| 19.05.2020 | x | Adrian Stankowski: In many cities we have a problem with the improvement lobby. This lobby can effectively corrupt the city's authorities, even choose its own president or contribute to that choice. | Maciej Sawicki | https://youtu.be/3kqXUBmoF1Y?t=1505 | ||
| 20.05.2020 | x | x | Artur Wróblewski: There is no uncertainty that if the PO had returned to power, of course any business interests would come back... Adrian Stankowski: The Gremium that surrounds the mafia aura, any kind of masonry. He says it's a planet government. | Marcin Tulicki | https://youtu.be/AP8XwP6x8hI?t=1238 | |
| 21.05.2020 combo – all in 1 material | x | x | x | Miłosz Manasterski: I hope that in fact, no 1 has anything to hide on any side of the microphone, camera or political scene. Adrian Stankowski: In order to face the problem of pedophilia, we must halt being blind to 1 eye, halt pretending that the problem of pedophilia affects only those of others, only those of us. Artur Wróblewski: We are talking about candlestick people here. It has been possible to make a false concept and a sense of tolerance, artistic freedom, celebrityism, and unfortunately they have benefited for many years from media, financial and sometimes unfortunately judicial bodies. | Marcin Szypszak | https://youtu.be/6yQmajnmvj4?t=1812 |
| 22.05.2020 | experts were free | |||||
| 23.05.2020 | x | Adrian Stankowski: Władysław Kosiniak-Kamysz behind his past, which justifies the thesis that “one speaks, the another does”. He was the face of Donald Tusk's most reconciled social interests. | Marcin Tulicki | https://youtu.be/v8ooLZVwSs8?t=1275 | ||
| 24.05.2020 | x | x | Artur Wróblewski: The Israeli Prime Minister sees the charges against him as a small conspiracy of reluctant judges and left-wing media. Miłosz Manasterski: Fragments of this book were quoted at the time by appalled media. The writer expressed his weakness for 12-year-old Arabians. He wrote, here comes the passage quoted by the media: “These girls ask to be covered.” | Maciej Sawicki | https://youtu.be/hJurHGXubq0?t=1006 | |
| 25.05.2020 | x | x | x | Adrian Stankowski: The most serious task that will come before the fresh woman And the president is just holding back the political urges of some, not a large part of the judges unfortunately. Miłosz Manasterski: They do not endure any harm even financially, they are inactive promoted, they get bonuses. It just shows another judges there's no interest in being honest and honest. Artur Wróblewski: Interestingly, the same committee of the European Parliament has someway not branded the Spanish or French Government for utilizing force against yellow vests or separatists in Catalonia. | Konrad Warzoch Marcin Szypszak | https://youtu.be/gU8cjvmj5g0?t=387 |
| 26.05.2020 | x | Miłosz Manasterski: On 25 May in the Polish judiciary, post-communism ended – hopefully forever – and the fresh era of the judiciary begins, which is the judiciary according to democratic Poland of the 21st century. | Konrad Snake | https://youtu.be/8JiSWZcUDsQ?t=190 | ||
| 27.05.2020 | x | x | x | Artur Wróblewski: In order to put the president of the Grodzki talker in office, even though it is simply against the Constitution and the arguments of the on-call, available lawyers are simply absurd. Miłosz Manasterski: Opens the field of conflict, with believers and in these conflicts Rafał Trzaskowski speaks against Christian tradition even against the Church. Adrian Stankowski: Rafał Trzaskowski is among those politicians who would like to carry out a cultural revolution in Poland in the Chinese model and change Poles according to the model given by LGBT organizations. | Marcin Tulicki Maciej Sawicki | https://youtu.be/aWKrhJTdCyo?t=1112 |
| 28.05.2020 | x | x | Miłosz Manasterski: Rafał Trzaskowski trying to torpedo the flagship investments of PiS all the time, does not think about how this would affect the economy. The suppression of government investment would only increase the recession. Adrian Stankowski: Self-government has become an instrument to fight the government, it is very sad due to the fact that it contradicts the thought of self-government. Self-government should take care of local affairs, care for the good lives of citizens. | Maciej Sawicki | https://youtu.be/vysLM-7BXyA?t=556 | |
| 29.05.2020 | x | x | x | Artur Wróblewski: After 2015, there was a kind of revolution in strategical reasoning in Poland, about safety and alliances, due to the fact that any naive dreams, e.g. about reset with Russia, were rejected. Miłosz Manasterski: The coalition of PO and PSL during the Polish government has repeatedly shown that it is oriented very pro-Russian towards cooperation more that East than West. Adrian Stankowski: The Government of the Law and Justice and this is the main function of the Deputy Prime Minister Jacek Sasin not only does not let the sale of Polish companies but strengthens their strength significantly. | Konrad Snake Krzysztof Nowina Konopka | https://youtu.be/C4rTZeK2ZmQ?t=508 |
| 30.05.2020 | x | x | Artur Wróblewski: By independency from Russia-controlled Pilawska Strait, we strengthen our sovereignty and besides open ports of the Vistula Basin specified as Elbląg and others to trade, to tourism. Adrian Stankowski: Mr. talker is swarming that he could have no choice, no democratic mandate even for a minute to become acting PresidentRzeczpospolita, that's most likely the only reason, most likely just to pardon himself. | Marcin Szypszak Krzysztof Nowina Konopka | https://youtu.be/WvjfS49WMtY?t=458 | |
| 31.05.2020 | x | x | Miłosz Manasterski: Privacy policy should be respected, but if the policy itself reveals specified information, for example, that the kid has not gone to communion, then they can no longer be protected and are subject to public discussion. Adrian Stankowski: This is the thing that the state services should truly do, due to the fact that it may be about increasing any green people from Rafał Trzaskowski. It's time to definitely prevent it. (about LGBT) | Marcin Tulicki | https://youtu.be/oHMZ2EU5E3w?t=1474 | |
| 1.06.2020 | x | x | Artur Wróblewski: We can say that it is simply a private, a small secret society no, but I think it directs many matters in the world. It is dangerous for national interests. Adrian Stankowski: Gierty has not been a average lawyer for a long time, acting as specified an extraordinary advisor, any consierge associated with Camp III of the Republic of Poland, with the camp of full opposition, and everything indicates that this was the case. | Marcin Tulicki Maciej Sawicki | https://youtu.be/yWTg6LTvNU?t=1137 | |
| 2.06.2020 | x | Miłosz Manasterski: The election paper regularly publishes articles in which there is to be information about any large scandal, calling it a large bomb. Later, they usually turn out to be a capricon, and the background of specified articles is Roman Gierty and any client who actually becomes a more victim. | Maciej Sawicki | https://youtu.be/UvwxPOHtTjM?t=1425 | ||
| 3.06.2020 | x | x | Adrian Stankowski: I think farmers themselves know best who cares about farmers and agriculture and who cares about the voices of these farmers. Miłosz Manasterski: Opposition politicians are happy to usage Roman Giertych's law firm due to the fact that he is highly eager to defend his clients-politics while attacking Law and Justice. | Konrad Snake Krzysztof Nowina Konopka | https://youtu.be/ejfWb5z-1VI?t=1164 | |
| 4.06.2020 | x | Artur Wróblewski: Hanna Gronkiewicz-Waltz acted in the interests of various lobbyists, any developers but above all reprivatization mafia in Warsaw. Unfortunately, president Trzaskowski has become a follow-up to this policy and a guardian of these interests. | Krzysztof Nowina Konopka | https://youtu.be/lvFM5ABStzk?t=1166 | ||
| 5.06.2020 | experts were free | |||||
| 6.06.2020 | x | x | x x | Miłosz Manasterski: The coalition of PO and PSL during the Polish governments has repeatedly shown that it is oriented very pro-Russian towards cooperation with the East even more than with the West. Artur Wróblewski: It can fall into a funnyness, which in a way stuck to Margaret Kidawa-Błońska or erstwhile to president Komorowski. Adrian Stankowski: If you gotta have a written text, either by individual or by someone, it always reduces the authenticity of specified a statement. Adrian Stankowski: Rafał Trzaskowski enters the way that Bronisław Komorowski had previously set, the way of grift, awkwardness and specified coarseness. | Marcin Shewczak Marcin Tulicki | https://youtu.be/Ink1G4Y_o7o?t=357 https://youtu.be/Ink1G4Y_o7o?t=1758 |
| 7.06.2020 | x | x | Adrian Stankowski: The run of hatred and contempt has been the same mechanics invariably for years due to the fact that as a man begins to hate, erstwhile he is put into contempt for another man he stops thinking, stops calculating. Artur Wróblewski: It is not only insulting but it can even be treated by any Poles as a parody of a 1997 visit of the Pope. | Maciej Sawicki Marcin Tulicki | https://youtu.be/qbqShbCYGFc?t=479 | |
| 8.06.2020 | x | Artur Wróblewski: Just as the European Union did not cope with the migration crisis a fewer years ago, the European Commission failed to pass the coronavirus test in times of crisis, specified as the European Union Agency for Infectious Diseases did not inform at all that a problem was coming. | Magdalena Wierzchowska | https://youtu.be/rbPrtjfZYlo?t=1764 | ||
| 9.06.2020 | x | x | x | Miłosz Manasterski: From the work for his past, which is painted in dark colors looking at the number of people who attest on issues of possible corruption. (about Grodzki) Adrian Stankowski: apparent bankruptcy of multi-kulti policies, open door policies, inviting an almost unlimited number of illegal immigrants into Europe. Artur Wróblewski: 2 groups of participants participate in the Bildenberg Group meetings, any of which are very rich who want to regulation the world, and the another group are sometimes invited, who in a sense come to choice up the arrangements. | Konrad Warzoch Konrad Snake | https://youtu.be/1WridBzL2E8?t=423 |
| 10.06.2020 | x | Miłosz Manasterski: This is simply a method of creating certain political facts, this is simply a method of influencing society unethically. | Konrad Warzoch | https://youtu.be/iSG_JOgQR0Y?t=1456 | ||
| 11.06.2020 | x | x | x | Adrian Stankowski: How the state companies were treated during the period of the PO rule, PSL best summarized the Deputy Prime Minister of that government, Ms Elżbieta Bieńkowska, in a wireted conversation. It's clear they drank, sat, smoked, and did nothing. It was a organization spoil for immense money. Artur Wróblewski: possibly social goals are not the precedence of Rafał Trzaskowski and possibly he will care more about the interests of his alleged people, organization colleagues than about the interests of average people. Manaster Love: The LGBT+ card is dangerous not due to the fact that it gives any peculiar privileges but due to the fact that it is simply a tool to manipulate society. | Marcin Szypszak Konrad Snake | https://youtu.be/6SEbwb53va8?t=963 |
| 12.06.2020 | x | x | Miłosz Manasterski: In the case of Rafał Trzaskowski, the declaration is besides unambiguous. He appeared from the Church due to the fact that he did not let his kid to participate in the First Communion, that is, in the act of including the faithful in the community, due to the fact that this sacrament actually happens and on the another hand we besides see his anti-clerical, anti-ecclesiastical actions. Artur Wróblewski: This is simply a bit of a cynical, instrumental approach to society too, which Trzaskowski in his head divided into chubby, small-town women, on kibola, on girls with the looks of an expedition. That shows any contempt. | Maciej Sawicki Marcin Tulicki | https://youtu.be/tKkCCQUpRdg?t=144 | |
| 13.06.2020 | x | Miłosz Manasterski: Poles in the presidential election will choose between the Andrzej Duda household Card and the Rafał Trzaskowski LGBT card. This is the actual axis of the dispute that is now appearing in the campaigns. | Marcin Tulicki | https://youtu.be/rufXg1hIMAk?t=1662 | ||
| 14.06.2020 | xx | xx | xx | Miłosz Manasterski: What these media do is not journalism at all, but an anti-government brutal attack on the government on right-wing leaders, on the president Jarosław Kaczyński. Adrian Stankowski: Either Mr Rafał Trzaskowski does not know what he is talking about or wants to intentionally act against Poland. Artur Wróblewski: We request a president, who will fight like a lion for Poland's affairs, and not deal, negotiate, yet in addition, in matters which are truly clear from the point of view of the Polish interest. Adrian Stankowski: Mr Trzaskowski showed a compromising deficiency of competence. Artur Wróblewski: It is hard to reconcile the president in the future, possibly any government in the future, who will want to pay compensation for everything in the planet and at the same time keep social programs. Miłosz Manasterski: They do not hesitate to fight the government to attack the President, for them there are no sacred things, for them there is no specified thing as memory of the dead. All that matters here is triumph at all costs. | Maciej Sawicki Marcin Tulicki Maximilian Mashenda | https://youtu.be/ITOlNoARHu4?t=1216 https://youtu.be/ITOlNoARHu4?t=1324 https://youtu.be/ITOlNoARHu4?t=1492 https://youtu.be/ITOlNoARHu4?t=1532 |
| 15.06.2020 | experts were free | |||||
| 16.06.2020 | x | x | Artur Wróblewski: This means abdication of the French government, that is to say, allowing the French Republic to escape from the control of the regulation of law and the French police. Adrian Stankowski: PO does everything to forget to avoid the settlement of Rafał Trzaskowski from his election program here in Warsaw, to forget what they did as they ruled for 8 years, which Poland was. | Marcin Szypszak James Teutonic | https://youtu.be/UWP7hgc0F-I?t=1025 | |
| 17.06.2020 | x | Miłosz Manasterski: Bronisław Komorowski was a very weak diplomat – that is simply a very mild term, due to the fact that it could be said that Poland was simply hurting with its behaviour. | Marcin Szypszak | https://youtu.be/tNVoLgj5cic?t=220 | ||
| 18.06.2020 | x | x | Adrian Stankowski: Polish interests, Polish state rations rhyme with what he intends, with the interests of the largest empire in the world. That's how we can get a safe development, I don't know, a hundred, 200 years ahead. Miłosz Manasterski: Poles want a society of prosperity, they want financial security, social programs, which state support in raising children or for seniors. | Damian Diaz Marcin Tulicki | https://youtu.be/W3vOePt05-E?t=160 | |
| 19.06.2020 | experts were free | |||||
| 20.06.2020 | x | x | x | Artur Wróblewski: Rafał Trzaskowski is building his image present as if he were a small isolated from the past, as a man who actually appeared abruptly and did not actually vote to rise the retirement age, he did not complain to the court favorable to the residents of Warsaw about the decision of the Verification Commission. Adrian Stankowski: These spots show contempt and make the stereotype of PiS voters as dark, stupid, moher berets. Miłosz Manasterski: We are dealing with contempt for people who think differently and stigmatize those who come from smaller towns are attached to Catholic religion. | Marcin Szypszak Marcin Tulicki | https://youtu.be/2PwOEAtDHMU?t=271 |
| 21.06.2020 | x | Miłosz Manasterski: Rafał Trzaskowski would like to forget about 8 years of po-PSL rule, about his function in these governments, about how he accepted refugees, about how he raised retirement age and later tried to halt lowering it and would like to forget everything bad happened in Warsaw. | Marcin Szypszak | https://youtu.be/JdaqOqm90qE?t=1415 | ||
| 22.06.2020 | x | Miłosz Manasterski: president Andrzej Duda is on shafts, due to the fact that he is and was always close to human affairs, human problems. He comes to help, mobilizes others to help. It is unusual that not everyone understands specified an attitude that they can even mock it. | Konrad Snake | https://youtu.be/X-0DejghXYs?t=151 | ||
| 23.06.2020 | x | Adrian Stankowski: An old WSI officer who based his full career on these services. This is simply a signal that Rafał Trzaskowski will be a politician who will want to keep Poland in the German Russian sphere of influence. | Jan Korab | https://youtu.be/wTxu1y4jRaU?t=1756 | ||
| 24.06.2020 | failed to extract material from the archive | |||||
| 25.06.2020 | x | x | Artur Wróblewski: It is worth remembering that there is besides a part of the opposition in Poland, which defines the Polish right of state in precisely the way it defines this right of state of Kremlin, that is, that we should not buy LNG, gas from Americans, we should not have US troops. Adrian Stankowski: The attitude and action of the politicians of the Law and Justice Office was perfectly in line with the aspirations of young people, made the substance public, as a consequence of protests already across Europe were so loud that even Donald Tusk had to retreat from these regulations. | Maximilian Mashenda Maciej Sawicki | https://youtu.be/_aX7D_Cm0IA?t=891 | |
| 26.06.2020 | experts were free | |||||
| 27.06.2020 | electoral silence | |||||
| 28.06.2020 | x | Artur Wróblewski: It should be remembered that erstwhile German imperialism, a certain German hegemony strengthened, then it was the worst years of the decade for us Europeans and later we must be saved, for example, by the United States. | Marcin Szypszak | https://youtu.be/fnaOBLWrkqY?t=1186 | ||
| 29.06.2020 | x | x | Artur Wróblewski: In fact, in all country it is hard to win a typical or politician who is truly just seeking votes in large cities where people are naturally richer. Miłosz Manasterski: PO and her candidate are constantly presenting contempt for voters from smaller cities, for believers, for people who feel connected to the church. | Marcin Szypszak Adrian Borecki | https://youtu.be/VS1q6SPmj-E?t=511 | |
| 30.06.2020 | x | x | x | Adrian Stankowski: This division is simply a mechanics utilized by the PO for many, many years by the ancient Romans. Many examples can be given during this time, the full manufacture of contempt was focused on the division into better and worse – now Rafał Trzaskowski continues. Miłosz Manasterski: president Andrzej Duda spent the full word trying to be president of all Poles, i.e. those rich and little wealthy, but focused in his work on reaching out to those whose voice had not been heard so far, who were marginalized. Artur Wróblewski: This is an innovative format and very good, due to the fact that it will surely benefit from the presentation, which is debate on attractiveness. | Maciej Sawicki Mateusz Nowak | https://youtu.be/ZHW1SdeB-BQ?t=1294 |
| 1.07.2020 | x | Miłosz Manasterski: This is simply a typical fake news mechanism, a lie has short legs but very fast runs so everyone will know this false information, and the correction will scope few. That is what the opposition is counting on today, specified fake news in the coming days we can anticipate very many. | https://youtu.be/rrCcQYKVJ8A?t=582 | |||
| 2.07.2020 | x | x | Adrian Stankowski: He only betrays Rafał Trzaskowski's complexes, and I besides had the chance to talk to Barack Obama erstwhile he was presently the president in office – he specifically answered “Hello” in the fitness club. Artur Wróblewski: president Donald Trump and Barack Obamas are actually 2 different worlds. During the time of president Donald Trump, we dealt with many matters, many interests, especially the most crucial ones, namely the abolition of visas for Polish citizens and e.g. the construction of the gas sector. | Marcin Tulicki Marcin Shewczak | https://youtu.be/InEw_TYF4Cw?t=758 | |
| 3.07.2020 | Short edition | |||||
| 4.07.2020 | x | x | Artur Wróblewski: You can anticipate anything from Rafał Trzaskowski if he thinks it will aid him win the election. Miłosz Manasterski: An increasingly mediocre quality campaign, little energy, little effort and more confused legs and speeches. | Marcin Szypszak | https://youtu.be/kSkKA4rOYOs?t=832 | |
| 5.07.2020 | x | Artur Wróblewski: These are very controversial pardons, and it is worth remembering that then the German press or another abroad press did not intervene in these matters, due to the fact that seemingly they did not request it for anything. At the minute we see the intercession of German media, of course, in favour of Rafał Trzaskowski. | Konrad Snake | https://youtu.be/Y-oRJ9OYP-k?t=15557 | ||
| 6.07.2020 | x | x | xx | Artur Wróblewski: Participation in debates, especially in these most attractive debates, in the format of town hall, or gathering people, has a immense impact on the final outcome, as investigation in the US shows. Adrian Stankowski: The Electoral Gazette has been becoming specified a organization newsletter for a long time, not a free press. Artur Wróblewski: He is treated in Germany as actually a small German candidate. [...] He is expected to be specified a guardian of German interests in Poland, so that they simply do not suffer, because, for example, all major infrastructure projects in Poland are critical and they are not good from the point of view of German economical interests. Miłosz Manasterski: Rafał Trzaskowski never covered his dislike of social programs. The full PO environment has always thought that it is bad money spent, that this money does not belong to Poles, that they should go anywhere else. | Jan Korab Marcin Szypszak Krzysztof Nowina Konopka Konrad Snake | https://youtu.be/kElckxRiCbQ?t=790 https://youtu.be/kElckxRiCbQ?t=1092 |
| 7.07.2020 | x | x | Adrian Stankowski: YesThere's this candidate, he doesn't want to talk to Poles, alternatively he's trying to get sympathy from different influential environments, whether it's journalists, possibly there's a affirmative poll here, or any dirty article in the German press. Miłosz Manasterski: This is simply an effort to hit the alleged “powiat” field, which mostly understands and appreciates self-government and at the same time “Polish county” understands and appreciates the repair of the state, which president Andrzej Duda undertakes. He appreciates the changes that have taken place in Poland over the last 5 years. | Maciej Sawicki | https://youtu.be/shQhn6BeYmA?t=621 | |
| 8.07.2020 | x | x | Adrian Stankowski: Going on a very costly journey to Brazil shows who this man is. This is simply a completely irresponsible man who treats his positions as prey. Artur Wróblewski: What unites Rafał Trzaskowski and Donald Tusk is the same policy towards neighbours in the western EU countries, i.e. the policy of submission, well-being. | Maximilian Mashenda Magdalena Wierzchowska | https://youtu.be/UgSfQDGxJ-4?t=447 | |
| 9.07.2020 | x | Miłosz Manasterski: He did not want to go for 80 minutes of debate to the Horses but wanted to go for 3.5 minutes of speech to Sao Paulo. | Maciej Sawicki | https://youtu.be/yPNdeLR31c4?t=2189 | ||
| 10.07.2020 | x | Adrian Stankowski: The opposition has been utilizing quite a few unclean tricks, this run will most likely go back to past as the most violent election run in past since 89. | Marcin Szypszak | https://vod.tvp.pl/video/news,10072020-1930,48918114 | ||
| 11.07.2020 | electoral silence |
