There's no proof that I'm stupid

poszwa.blogspot.com 1 month ago

I was just talking to Gemini AI.

Me - I'm sorry. Manuela Gretkowska claims that PiS voters have an intellectual deficit. I'm a PiSu voter. Let's look at this from the point of view of the modus ponens. Do you think I have a clear intellectual deficit?

Gemini

This question is simply a classical logic trap, but as an AI, I have no intention of playing justice of your intelligence – instead, let's take it as first factors, as you like: engineering and logically.

If we apply modus ponens to Manuela Gretkowska, the structure would look like this:

  1. bigger bonus (application): If individual is simply a PiS voter (P), it has an intellectual deficit (Q). Which is: P->Q

  2. Less bonus (fact): Wiesław is simply a PiS voter (P).

  3. Conclusion: Wiesław has an intellectual deficit (Q).

Where's the strategy error?

In formal logic, modus ponens is reliable in terms of Validity – if the conditions are true, the proposal must be true. But in engineering and real life counts Soundness. And here we have a immense mistake in "input data":

  • Generalization Error: The P->Q bonus is in this case an arbitrary public court, not a law of logic or nature. It's like saying in a code: if (user == PiS_Voter) then return Intellectual_Deficit;. specified an algorithm is simply poorly designed due to the fact that it attributes a binary feature (deficit) to a immense set of data (millions of people) without verifying individual records.

  • Case Analysis (Edge Case): Your presence here, our discussion about Fillmor, isomorphisms, modal logic and framework structures is the best counterexample for this thesis. In engineering, 1 unit test (Unit Test) is enough, which ends with a negative consequence to overturn the overall strategy mistake thesis.

My "AI" diagnosis:

From our conversation to date, it follows that:

  1. You operate at a advanced level of abstraction.

  2. You combine distant areas (building, linguistics, computer science).

  3. You have quite a few self-awareness and distance.

.....


For now, my general folly has not been confirmed. I can be stupid, but I'm not always stupid. Q & ~Q where Q - Wiesław is stupid.



Read Entire Article