In fresh years Poland has seen an increase in the number of reports made by citizens on their neighbours. This phenomenon raises many controversy and questions about the origin and consequences of specified behavior.
Reports statistic in Poland
According to data from 2019, about 50 1000 donations were received from taxation offices in Poland. By comparison, 5 years earlier, this number was just 2 000, which means an increase of 2400%. On average, this means about 10 notifications a day. Most of them afraid neighbouring settlements specified as not issuing receipts, renting non-tax housing, or hiring employees in black.
Other institutions besides reported an increase in the number of reports. For example, in 2013 530 messages were received in the taxation Chamber in Warsaw, while in 2014 there were 814 of them. akin trends were observed in another major cities specified as Wrocław, Bydgoszcz or Kielce.
Motivation of Informers
Analysis of the content of the notes indicates that they are most frequently submitted by neighbors, household members or erstwhile employees. The motivations may be varied:
- Jealousy: The financial success of a neighbour or a fresh car may awaken resentment and prompt a tip.
- Feeling Unrighteous: Those who feel that individual is avoiding paying taxes or breaking the law may feel obliged to inform the applicable services.
- Personal conflicts: vicinity disputes or household misunderstandings frequently lead to reports of revenge.
Effectiveness of the reports
Despite the expanding number of reports, the efficiency of the reports remains comparatively low. According to estimates, only 2-3% of cases end in criminal punishment or taxation liability. This means that most reports are not actually confirmed or lacked evidence of wrongdoing.
Social perception of informatics
Intelligence in Poland has a long and complicated history, dating back to the times of partitions and PRL. Modern society is divided in the assessment of this phenomenon. For some, it is an expression of the civic attitude and concern for compliance with the law, for others – a manifestation of deficiency of loyalty and interference in the private lives of others.
CBOS investigation from 2024 shows that 80% of Poles declare that they have good neighbours on which they could count. However, despite the declared openness to neighbouring contacts, the number of reports indicates tensions and conflicts in human relations.
Legal and ethical implications
Fake reporting can lead to serious legal consequences for the whistleblower. According to Polish law, a individual consciously making a false notification of a crime may be fined, restricted or sentenced to 2 years.
From an ethical point of view, reporting can lead to erosion of assurance in local communities, deepening conflicts and social isolation of those active in specified activities.
How do you deal with reports?
Persons who have fallen victim to wrongful allegations should:
- Stay calm.: Do not respond impulsively and avoid escalation of conflict.
- Contact your lawyer.: Get professional legal advice to defend your rights.
- Document the situation: Collect evidence of innocence, specified as photographs, recordings or witness statements.
In the event of persistent harassment of reports, it is besides possible to study the case to law enforcement authorities due to slander or stalking.
More here:
Neighbors study neighbors. That hasn't happened yet.
