An open letter to Donald Tusk: “There would be no Hamas if it were not for Israel”

Agnes Piwar 2025-08-04 https://piwar.info/list-open-to-donalda-tuka-no-was-hamasu-if-not-Israel/

Nakba, or Arabic “catastrophe”

=================================================================

Prime Minister,

I ask you to remember and refrain from expressing opinions that They are very damaging to the global image of Poland.

On 3 August, on platform X, you wrote:
«Poland was, is and will be on the side of Israel in his confrontation with muslim terrorism, but never on the side of politicians whose actions lead to hunger and death of mothers and children. It must be apparent to the nations who have shared the hell of planet War II.»

Well, if you listened to the voice of the Polish Nation – which I do not fishy you – you would know that Poland (i.e. the country that most Poles live in) is definitely not on the side of Israel.

I'll explain to you as scapologically as possible.

Israel has been violently occupying Palestine for decades (as during planet War II the Germans occupied Poland).

The judaic founders of Israel in 1948 stole the Palestinian land on which they began building their Zionist state creation. Parallel began Nakba, or Arabic “catastrophe” – this is the word for Palestinians for the 1947–1949 drama erstwhile after the uprising of Israel around 750,000 people were forced to leave their homes, and hundreds of villages were destroyed or ravaged. Israel occupied the territory much larger than the UN Resolution had foreseen.

Nakba's inactive alive. present millions of Palestinian refugees live in diaspora, without the right to return.

Meanwhile, the Palestinians who remained in the land occupied by Israel, The fundamental rights needed to be have been stripped. It is adequate to mention that for respective decades they have been deprived of their right to life and safety (a threat from military activities, attacks, limited access to wellness care), the right to usage natural resources and land (limited access to water and agricultural land, forced displacement, expansion of judaic settlements), the right to free movement (number of blockades, checkpoints, restrictions on entry and exit from Gaza and the West Bank), the right to self-determination and political participation (limited through permanent occupation).

Since the beginning of the occupation, Israel has been utilizing perfidious methods of humiliating and destroying Palestinians. These methods should be included arbitrary, mass arrests – including children and women. Palestinians endure and die in prisons frequently without an indictment, only on the basis of “secret” evidence which, as we know from its own history, the occupier can come up with a wait.

It is estimated that Since 1967 (after the Six-Day War) to this day, more than 1 million Palestinians have been detained in Israeli prisons – about 20% of the full Palestinian population and 40% of the male population. To go to Israeli prison, it is enough, for example, to find a paper or a evidence with Palestinian music calling for freedom. Sometimes the reason for arrest may be to look at it as inappropriate. Sometimes all it takes is simply a speech of voice or a strong personality to be detained and deprived of liberty.

Palestinian prisoners are systematically tortured. The most commonly utilized methods include beating, electrical shock, strangulation, long-term isolation, sleep deprivation and utmost cold retention. Inmates in Israeli prisons besides experience sexual violence, including collective rape. Many victims are stripped bare and forced into humiliating positions.

Children are held in dark cells, intimidated and brutally interrogated, frequently without the presence of a lawyer or guardian. These actions constitute a serious violation of global law and are considered to be a form of systemic repression.

In the light of these facts, do you consider the “Islamic terrorists” persecuted for decades by Palestinians who are simply trying to last in hard reality? Since you spoke in consequence to Tom Rose's comment, a candidate for the US Ambassador to Poland, to the words of Radosław Sikorski, head of the Ministry of abroad Affairs, it is not hard to conclude that Mr Hamas is “Islamic terrorists”. So let me explain where these organizations come from.

Hamas is simply a Palestinian opposition movement that was born in consequence to the Israeli occupation.

Israel introduced apartheid – an organization racial segregation strategy in which 1 ethnic, national or racial group dominates and discriminates against another, taking distant its fundamental civil, social and political rights. In this case, we are dealing with judaic settlers who persecute Palestinians.

There would be no Hamas and his actions – including those of the armed ones – if the judaic settlers had not occupied the Palestinian land and deprived them of all rights, including the right to life.

The action produces a reaction! This means that each action has a certain effect or response. I advise you to think about it, due to the fact that as head of government, he should know these mechanisms and respect them.

Bottom line:

What is happening present in Palestine is solely the responsibility of Israel—a Zionist state creature that occupies the land of others. Anyone who takes his side collaborates with evil.

Agnes Piwar
Polish journalist, author of the book "Palestinian Holocaust"