One ship – different captains. BRICS Group after enlargement

Analysis briefly:

• BRICS – a political and economical format of Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa – was extended to include fresh members this year. Egypt, Ethiopia, United arabian Emirates and Iran joined the forum. Despite announcements from the entrance, Argentina withdrew, and Saudi Arabia inactive has not officially confirmed its membership.
• Cooperation includes the improvement of investments (New improvement Bank), infrastructure and sport, but key initiatives specified as Deeper Banking, Digital and safety Cooperation stay the subject of declarations without real action.
• The founding countries combine the search for an alternate to the US way of doing politics, while they share the view of deeper integration, especially erstwhile China is increasingly pushing it.
• The PRC is liable for about 2/3 of the full organisation's GDP.

With the extension of 5 fresh states in early January 2024, the BRICS group (Brazil, Russia, India, China & South Africa – an acronym formed from the first letters of the founding states' names) doubled its size. The block, whose birth was predicted by US banks[1] since 2001, was created in 2006 by the first 4 states defining themselves as “emerging markets” with Russia returning to the planet economical game, and the another countries aspiring to the top. From the association of dynamic economies based on natural materials (Russia), sleeping in populous populations of possible (China and India as the most populous countries of the world) and leading political function in their regions, However, BRICS slow became a non-collective club Western autocracy first under the auspices of Moscow, and in fresh years increasingly assertive Beijing. With further applications and observations sent to the organization, the Johannesburg Summit (August 2023) decided to accept fresh members, which was the second extension since the format was created.

History and key initiatives

The first 4 countries – BRIC – met in Yekaterinburg in June 2006 to discuss the current economical situation, economical recession and the request to share the communicative of emerging marketplace leaders[2]. At the next 2010 summit, South Africa hosted as an observer and possible candidate[3].

BRICS does not have a secretariat. The only organization pillars of the organization are proposed in 2013 and created in 2014 financial institutions: fresh improvement Bank and the BRICS Contingent Reserve Arrangement mechanism. Both were set up in the framework of the alleged Fortelase Declaration, which includes provisions on economical cooperation between countries, common designation of diplomas, joint financing of infrastructure projects and SDGs[4].

It is typical to organise combined summits in conjunction with another intergovernmental forums at the head of which the summit is hosted and in which all or most BRICS countries are associated. The first example was a combined summit with the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) and the Euro-Asian economical Union (EAEU) in Ufa in July 2015. Another specified summit was a gathering in Benauli, India in 2016 in cooperation with the global method and economical Initiative for the Cooperation of the Gulf of Bengal (BIMSTEC) or the 2018 Xiamen Summit, where China invited members of the dialog of Emerging Markets and Developing States (EMDCD)[5].

In 2016, countries signed the alleged Goa Declaration as a paper ending the eighth summit[6]. On the 10th Summit (June 2018) hosted by South Africa in Johannesburg, the issue of "rising industries" and the place of the BRICS countries in the high-tech marketplace were addressed. The gathering continued a year later in Brasilia, where the 11th Summit dominated the slogan of technological and innovative cooperation or the first thought of the single digital currency.

Summits in the pandemic crisis hosted by Russia (2020) and India (2021) were held online. Another stationary gathering (14th Summit) in Beijing in 2022 resulted in the thought of establishing a common reserve basket currency as counterweight for the dollar monopoly.

The last summit in 2023 was commented out loud due to Vladimir Putin's online speech, which did not arrive at the gathering in fear of the allegations of the global Criminal Court[7].

Shortly before that date, after the presidential election and Javier Millei's win from entry to BRICS, Argentina withdrew[9]. Saudi Arabia has besides ratified the agreement, but has not yet joined; at the beginning of the year Saudi state tv announced its accession to the organisation, after which it removed the communication, information remains contradictory in terms of actual joining[10♪[11].

Initiatives worth noticing include the task of the BRICS Cable underwater fiber-optic communication strategy (4th Summit in fresh Delhi, 2012), BRICS Games – yearly multidisciplinary sports championships organised by associate States since 2017, or the proposed financial settlement strategy alternate to the Western SWIFT since 2015. Due to different visions of operation and the existence of its own systems in at least 3 BRICS countries (Brazil and Russia is developing, China has partially implemented the CIPS – Cross-border Interbank Payment System) it has not yet achieved a common plan or even a position[12].

Economy

BRICS members – mostly large, diverse countries and thus national – represent the full economical spectrum: from global production potentials, through suppliers of key natural materials, to countries in a complex economical and social situation. Among these are the second (China), 5th (India), ninth (Russia) and eleventh (Brazil) of the world's largest economies.

Table 1. Founders of BRICS – GDP and population. planet Bank data[13]

Table 2. fresh members of BRICS – GDP and population. planet Bank data

As many as 4 participating countries make a key part of their income from trade in natural materials, mainly energy (petroleum, natural gas, fuel and petroleum products – 3 OPEC and Russia)[14], coal (China and Russia), metallic ores (Brazil: 2nd place in iron and manganese extraction, 3rd a tin market) or precious stones (diamonds from South Africa, Brazilian emeralds)[15]. 7 format countries usage atomic energy to varying degrees. China, Brazil and the United arabian Emirates are besides major players in the renewable energy marketplace (China in practice dominated the world’s PV marketplace – around 80% of planet production in 2023)[16]. The participation of the BRICS countries in advanced technology is besides increasing. Having a drop in mass from the USSR, Russia has been intensively modernizing the arms and rocket manufacture in fresh years. Brazilian Embraer is 1 of the world's leading aviation manufacturers. China is the world's largest digital marketplace saturated with giant software and hardware technologies. tiny in comparison with another countries, the arabian Emirates is building its brand as a connecting planet of transport hubs and technology, and Saudi Arabia is creating itself as the leader of energy transition, while remaining an oil exporter. 3 of the BRICS countries (Russia, China and India) have advanced space programs with full capacity to bring cargo to orbit and conduct orbital and interplanetary missions[17].

The group's most crucial financial centers are Shanghai, Shenzhen and Hong Kong (China), Riyadh (Saudi Arabia), Mumbai (India), Johannesburg, South Africa, and Emirati Dubai where the largest of the world's markets are located. The fresh improvement Bank mentioned earlier has a office in Shanghai and its objectives and structure are akin to another multilateral banking institutions specified as the planet Bank. Similarly, NDB has a board of governors and multi-level management, and its mission is to support global projects, improve quality of life or fill in SDGs, but has a much smaller scope limited to BRICS members and smaller resources (start capital of US$100 billion divided in parity)[18]. As a 10-year-old institution, NDB is inactive comparatively small; since its inauguration, it has approved USD 30.23 billion, including 2.7 billion in 2022. The planet Bank Group mobilised USD 70.8 billion for comparison in the same year[19♪[20♪[21]

Military capabilities

Among the members of the truly global military power remains Russia with a full-scale atomic triad, an ocean fleet (with advanced submarines), long-range aviation and an extended military space infrastructure. An crucial player is China with the largest force in the world, with attempts at hypersonic weapons, or a rapidly expanding naval navy with coastal forces and 2 aircraft carrier combat groups (third in preparation for duty). India and Brazil, whose large armed forces effectively implement national and imported weapons systems from abroad, besides deserve peculiar attention. “India has atomic submarines, Brazil is working on ship-based reactors for propulsion purposes.

Other countries, i.e. Iran, Arabia, South Africa, Ethiopia or Egypt are regional powers frequently with unique capabilities resulting from their geopolitical environment, e.g. deprived of access to Ethiopia's coast focuses on the expansion of an air-supported land army, Iran has an advanced ballistic programme and peculiar services – both of which are the subject of an global safety debate in the mediate East. The equipment of the smaller BRICS army mostly represents a decline after the Cold War or comes from import e.g. equipment of the Royal Saudi Armed Forces mostly purchased in the U.S., Egypt's armament comes from France, Ethiopia operates russian aircraft and combat vehicles models, etc. A tiny but consistently developed army organizes the Emirates aspiring to the function of safety broker in the Persian Gulf. Defence investments are designed to increase mobility, usage drone technology, satellite designation and precise air strikes.

Conclusions for the future and directions for improvement of BRICS

BRICS is inactive a loose strategy with a low level of formalisation and institutionalization. While remaining a group of leaders of the various macroregions, it shows sensitivity to their differences of opinion (China-India, China-Russia, Brazil's low interest). The organisation's objectives are very general, frequently in the field of declaration, which differs from multilevel governance projects specified as the European Union. The strengthening of relations is blocked by common distrust of partners towards each other, and the number of fields of possible conflicts of interest increases alternatively of decreasing (technology, influence in government on AI, the South China Sea, territorial disputes in the Himalayas, demography and social inequality as a challenge in almost all format countries).

It is so more likely that the little formalised nature of an organisation geared towards intergovernmental/inter-ministerial contacts and financial co-operation favouring China as the main payer and supplier of method services (New improvement Bank quaker in Shanghai[22, investment projects and their lending linked to the Chinese Belt and way initiative, etc.) than the institutionalization of Russia, for example, in the EAEU. A separate opinion on this issue is presented by India, whose influences in the planet are growing, and the competition with China is expanding – the more improbable it is to further strengthen links, peculiarly monetary, intelligence and defence. It is improbable that specified a close-up will take Delhi. The plan of the single currency, e-money and the clearing strategy is so called into question, although its very creation would mean a convenient strategy to counter possible Western sanctions. Stronger economical co-operation between America, Europe and the Indopacity can become an crucial weakening origin for BRICS+ members, but integrating their cooperation. The emergence of geopolitical tensions could force BRICS to have greater military coordination and trade in military technologies, and the increase in global protectionism could stimulate interior consumption of economies specified as South Africa or the mediate East, and what is already happening in China.

Despite its enlargement in 2024, BRICS/BRICS+ remains the coordination club of countries seeking an alternate policy way towards the United States – they represent a spectrum of systems from autocracy to democratic yet assertive actors seeking balance in an increasingly multipolar reality. It is hard to talk of BRICS as a political/military alliance and its further integration, although it will be possible to proceed alternatively according to Chinese expectations and projects. A further 34 countries have now applied for membership. The final decision of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia may be of large importance to their attitude towards the format.

Photo: pexels.com

Bibliography

[1] O’Neill, J. “Building better global economical BRICs”, Global Economics Paper 2001, No. 66.

[2] ‘They might be giants. A peculiar study on banking in emerging markets", The Economist of 15 May 2010.

[3] ‘A wall of BRICS’: The signature of adding six fresh members to the bloc, Al Jazeera, https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/8/24/analysis-wall-of-brics-the-significance-of-adding-six-new-members, accessed: 2024/01/30

[4] Fortelaza Declaration made at Fortelaza on 15 July 2014, https://www.brics2018.org.za/sites/default/files/documents/Fortaleza%20Declaration.pdf, accessed: 2024/01/30

[5] VIII Xiamen Summit, http://brics2022.mfa.gov.cn/eng/gyjzgj/ljldrhwcgwj/202202/t20220222_10644353.html, accessed: 2024/01/30

[6] Declaration of the Goa (8th BRICS Summit: Goa Declaration), done at Goa on 16 October 2016, http://www.brics.utoronto.ca/docs/161016-goa.html, accessed: 2024/01/30

[7] Putin was meant to be at a summary in South Africa this week. Why were you asked to stay away?, AP, https://apnews.com/article/brics-xi-jinping-putin-china-russia-963108da4d389f8e1e7775c9e002b5f9, accessed: 2024/01/30

[8] BRICS MASSIVE EXPENSION: Russia Is Chair In 2024, fresh strategical Members, Focus Areas For fresh Year. Lena Petrova – CFA Finance, Economics & Tax, https://www.youtube.com/embed/0W_ihJeZkhY&ab_channel=LenaPetrova%2CCPA-Finance%2CEconomics%26Tax, accessed: 2024/01/30

[9] Argentina regiments out of plans to join Brics bloc, BBC https://www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-67842992, accessed: 2024/01/30

[10] BRICS gets boost as Saudi Arabia joins group of emerging nations, Bloomberg, https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-01-31/brics-gets-boost-as-saudi-arabia-joins-group-of-emerging-nations, accessed: 2024/02/28

[11] Saudi Arabia has not yet joined BRICS – Saudi authoritative source, Reuters, https://www.reuters.com/world/saudi-arabia-has-not-yet-joined-brics-saudi-official-source-2024-02-01/, accessed: 2024/02/28

[12] Karwowski, K. (2022). Dragon quantums. Chinese computerization in financial technologies. In: Górka, J. & Zemigala, M. FinTech Miscellanea (pp. 172–182). Wydawnictwo UW, Wyd. Section WZ UW. https://doi.org/10.7172/978-83-235-5939-9.swz.13.9

[13] planet Bank Open Data – Free and open access to global improvement date: www.data.worldbank.org, accessed: 2024/01/30

[14] OPEC website: https://www.opec.org/opec_web/en/about_us/25.htm, accessed: 2024/01/30

[15] Huang, J. (2024). Resources, innovation, globalization, and green growth: The BRICS financial improvement strategy. Geoscience Frontiers, 15(2), 101741. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gsf.2023.101741

[16] China Solar Exports Report. Ember-Climate, https://ember-climate.org/insights/research/china-solar-exports/, accessed: 2024/01/30

[17] Karwowski, K. (2024a) The Competition Among Stars: Case Studies of American-Russian-Chinese Rivalry in Space Exploration. In: Pietrzak, P. [Ed.] Dealing With Regional Conflicts of Global Importance (2024a). IGI Global, DOI: 10.4018/978-1-6684-9467-7 (in the publishing process)

[18] fresh improvement Bank: Capital structure and subscription, https://www.ndb.int/about-ndb/shareholding/ , accessed: 2024/02/28

[19] Srinivas, P.S. & Hofman, B. fresh improvement Bank’s function in the global financial architecture. GPJ, https://www.globalpolicyjournal.com/blog/25/2022/new-development-banks-role-international-financial-architeture, accessed: 2024/03/05

[20] NDB yearly study 2022. https://www.ndb.int/annual-report-2022/pdf/NDB_AR_2022_complete.pdf, accessed: 2024/03/05

[21] yearly Report. planet Bank Lending (Fiscal 2022). WB, https://thedocs.worldbank.org/en/doc/cd9fa1e2938c3eb6483e9e2fc0aed728-0090012022/original/WBAR22-App-FY22-Lending-Presentation.pdf Accessed: 2024/03/05

[22] BRICS' fresh improvement Bank HQ, Shanghai, China. Flowcon, https://flowcon.com/projects/brics-new-development-bank-hq-shanghai, accessed: 2024/01/30