French schools from CM1 to elder advanced school celebrated for the first time mandatoryly on 11 November 2026: a minute of silence, a Marseillen and a memory of the dead behind France. Left-wing teaching unions called for boycotts, speaking of "militarisation". The dispute shows how profoundly part of the European Left rejects the common national memory today.
Obligation from 4th grade primary school
The French Ministry of Education introduced compulsory celebrations on 11 November in all primary schools, advanced schools and advanced schools in the school year 2026/2027. Students from CM1, i.e. the equivalent of Polish 4th grade primary school, participate in them until the last grade of advanced school. The ceremonies are held within 4 working days before or after the feast.
As shown by Official Communication of the French Ministry of Education, the state justifies the decision with the request to build national cohesion and to remember those who risked their lives in defence of France. The school ceremony includes a gathering of students, a minute of silence and a singing of the Marseillen. It is besides possible to appeal the fallen, to exposure the flag and to participate in military and government representatives.
This is not military training or organization agitation. Children don't get guns and practice drills. They worship people who died for their own country. The difference is fundamental, although for part of the left, simply recalling the nation, the anthem, and the victims of the fallen are adequate to declare an alarm.
Relationships call for boycotts
SNES-FSU, an influential union of advanced school teachers, reacted the hardest. The organization demanded the withdrawal of the ministerial circular and guide, supported staff refusing to participate and allowed boycotts in the form of a strike. W SNES-FSU position The celebrations were presented as instrumentalization of pupils and part of the expected militarisation of the school.
The opposition was besides raised by FSU-SNUipp, SUD Éducation and CGT Éduc'action. The unions mention the freedom of pedagogy, the fear of military presence and the request to separate past teaching from the authoritative memorial ritual. Part of this dispute concerns the way the decision is implemented and can be debated wisely. The school chief shouldn't be doing a political rally. However, it does not appear that the common minute of silence and the anthem are an attack on education.
Memory and past are not enemies
Left-wing argument is based on false opposition. Accurate teaching of past explores the sources, shows the suffering of civilians and explains the causes of war. National memory gives this cognition a Community dimension. 1 doesn't take the place of the other. A nation that knows the names of the fallen and understands the price of its freedom does not want war. He's getting more mature.
The French dispute is peculiarly meaningful, due to the fact that on 11 November it commemorates the end of planet War I and all the dead for France. It's a day of triumph and peace. Calling specified a ceremony as militarization shows ideological distrust of the concept of homeland itself.
In Poland This year's celebration on 11 November combined marches, parades and live national memory. However, we besides have attempts to treat patriotism as an embarrassing addition to education. Disputes over the memory of soldiers and state standards of commemoration callback that the community will not follow the procedures themselves.
Rate besides for Poland
For Poles, the French fight is simply a warning. A school deprived of national memory brings up a citizen without rooting, easy convinced that sovereignty, boundaries and victims of erstwhile generations are a suspicious past. specified education weakens the state's ability to defend itself erstwhile safety is no longer a theory.
A patriotic ceremony must be wise, calm and based on truth. He should besides stay a shared experience. The French authorities rightly felt that the memory of the dead should be passed on to the full generation, not only to students whose teacher or household had already been curious in history. The left may argue for details. However, there is no right to present love for the homeland as a illness from which the school should cure the children.
Sources: Polish Radio Rzeszów, French Ministry of Education, SNES-FSU, Fondation Jean-Jaurès
Source: Polish Radio Rzeszów











