In fresh days, a discussion about the anticipation of introducing a taxation for children has begun in Poland. This thought was initiated by the presidential candidate Mark Jakubiak, who claims that those who do not have children should pay an additional tribute, which during the PRL period was called "the bull". Will Poland take this step?
History of taxation for childless
Tax for childless is not a fresh idea. In history, it took place in the russian Union, where since the 1940s, the alleged "motherhood defence tax" was introduced, which afraid men and unmarried women over the age of 25 without children. akin solutions besides functioned in any east bloc countries, specified as Romania, where fees aimed at expanding fertility in society. Today, the taxation for childless people is in place in any EU countries, specified as Germany and France.
Arguments in favour and against
Adversaries of a childless taxation claim that the introduction of specified a tribute could be unfair to those who do not have children for reasons beyond their control, specified as wellness problems or surviving conditions. Critics besides argue that specified a taxation discriminates against people who deliberately quit having children, choosing another forms of social commitment or investing in individual development.
Tax supporters, on the another hand, say that childless people should be more supportive of the strategy utilized by families raising future taxpayers. They propose that singles pay an additional tribute, which would be equal to the amount that parents receive under the ‘800 plus’ scheme.
Political positions
President-designate Marek Jakubiak advocates the introduction of a taxation for the childless, while Marcelina Zawisza of the organization Together believes that specified a tribute would be cruel to those who face the problem of infertility. Jarosław Rzepa of PSL, on the another hand, prefers solutions related to work safety or expanding the availability of nurseries and kindergartens. Urszula Rusecka of the Law and Justice Office considers the proposal to be “reconsiderable” due to the fact that the situations of people with and without children are completely different.
Reliable data from Poland
According to GUS data, in 2020 34.6% of Poles aged 25-49 had no children, which accounts for about 4.5 million people. In this case, the introduction of a taxation for childless could bring crucial financial benefits to the State. However, we should besides consider the arguments of the opponents of this thought and consider whether the introduction of specified a tribute would be fair and effective.
Test results
Research conducted by the Institute for economical investigation showed that among Poles who do not have children, 45% believe that an additional taxation for the childless should be introduced, while 42% are opposed to this idea. investigation conducted by CBOS showed that 67% of Poles believe that families with children should receive financial support from the state.
Conclusion
The introduction of a taxation for childless people in Poland is simply a controversial thought that inspires many emotions and discussions. The arguments for and against should be considered to make a decision that is fair and effective for all parties. At the same time, regardless of the decision to be taken, it should be remembered that financial support for families with children should be a precedence in order to give them the chance to live decently and make their offspring.
Read more:
Will Poland introduce a taxation for the childless? Discussion of the controversial idea
