Bodnar gives hints to Domański in the case of a pato-cleaning of the illegal SN Control Chamber on the PiS case

dailyblitz.de 10 months ago

On Thursday, August 29, the State Election Commission (PPP) decided to reject the accounts of Law and Justice (PiS) from last year's parliamentary elections. This decision sparked a wave of comments and speculation, and the PiS itself announced an appeal to the ultimate Court. The final verdict in this case remains uncertain, especially in the context of controversy surrounding the home of Extraordinary Control and Public Affairs, which will settle the case. This case has far-reaching implications for the Polish electoral strategy and the regulation of law in the country.

PKW rejects the financial statements of the Law and Justice: Decision without precedent

The decision of the Polish Academy of Sciences to reject the accounts of the Polish Academy of Sciences marks the highest financial punishment in the past of Polish politics. Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki responded quickly, announcing that the organization disagreed with this decision and intends to appeal to the ultimate Court. This right is granted to any organization that feels affected by the decision of the PKW.

Chamber of Extraordinary Control and Public Affairs: A origin of controversy

While the appeal of the Law and Justice to the ultimate Court seems to be a natural step, the substance is complicated erstwhile we consider the home of Extraordinary Control and Public Affairs. This is the chamber that's going to be investigating the cancellation of the Law and Justice. This home was created as a consequence of the improvement of the judiciary, which transferred work for settling public matters from the Chamber of Labour, Social Insurance and Public Affairs. It was criticised from the very beginning, as reflected in the December judgement of the Court of Justice of the European Union (TEU) of 2023. The Court found that the functioning of the Extraordinary Control Chamber was incompatible with EU law.

"This is not just a substance of assessment of the EUSF" – Adam Bodnar

Adam Bodnar, Minister of Justice and lawyer General, pointed out serious doubts about the legality of judgments issued by the Extraordinary Control Chamber. In his interview with Polish Radio, he emphasized that "the judgement may be affected by a defect due to the fact that we have doubts whether it is simply a court at all". The problem is not limited to the assessment by the EU Court of Human Rights or the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg. Bodnar pointed out that even inside the Chamber itself there were doubts – 3 judges refused to rule, arguing this with the unregulated position of the Chamber in accordance with the Constitution.

Conclusions for the Finance Minister

In this context, Adam Bodnar called on the Minister of Finance to consider the consequences of decisions given by the Extraordinary Control Chamber. “The Minister of Finance should think very seriously about what lessons to learn from specified a decision, if specified a decision is to be made,” Bodnar said. This remark suggests that crucial legal and financial implications for the government are possible in the event of the cancellation of the Law and Justice Offices being declared invalid.

Possible scenario: Illegal ultimate Court Audit Chamber upholds PKW decision

Although the PiS announces a fight to change the PKW decision, Adam Bodnar does not regulation out a script in which the ultimate Court will reject the party's appeal and confirm the PKW ruling. past shows that in most cases appeals against the PKW decisions concerning the financial statements of the parties were rejected. Let's wait and see. There may be no problem, due to the fact that the Extraordinary Control Chamber can confirm the activities of PKW," Bodnar stated, adding that specified a script is possible.

Law and work to control PKW

In the context of this case, there are besides voices of criticism that PKW has exceeded its competence by examining the financial statements of the Law and Justice Office besides widely. Adam Bodnar definitely disagrees with that view. He stresses that PKW had not only a right but a work to carry out a detailed inspection. – This is simply a situation where it cannot be considered that the control by PKW is only formal, that we check only the posts and tables presented by election committees. You gotta scope out to the point – Bodnar assessed.

Summary

The decision of PKW to reject the accounts of the Law and the possible appeal to the ultimate Court puts the Polish legal strategy before another challenge. The controversies around the home of Extraordinary Control and Public Affairs and the 2023 judgement of the EUSEU show difficulties in resolving the case. The final decision may have far-reaching consequences not only for the Law and Justice, but besides for the full electoral process in Poland.

Read more:
Bodnar gives hints to Domański in the case of a pato-cleaning of the illegal SN Control Chamber on the PiS case

Read Entire Article